The 2nd one looks a bit better bc of the meat content/protein content - but not all of the info is really here. Is the flax seed just seed? If so, don't bother - like humans, flax
seed is just eliminated undigested - is has to be ground or given as extracted oil. And, is your dog sensitive to flax (something to consider)? And, I wonder what "egg product" is? I mean, it looks pretty good overall - but sometimes you can get more ingredient info if you keep snooping around...