I just read some of the posts on the thread you're refering to.
sorry, but it stuck out a mile that he/she was going and going until someone had to finally bite, this seemed the purpose of the thread, and then when they got what they want.... play the victim and say you're all bad and i'm leaving!
people on YT are passionate about their dogs and if you post and dont expect to get some passionate answers back then you shouldnt use a forum. If i were that convinced with something i was doing, it wouldnt bother me what others thought, i wouldnt need to seek approval and then become upset if i didnt get it. jmoi