[centralnewyorki]

Originally Posted by kewtee

Sorry, but as I said I haven't seen all the TV about celebrities, as it interests me not at all.
But the example you mention has nothing to do with his love for the girl and you have to keep those things seperate. You have to judge every person on every act and not let one act judge the person, because if you do, none of us are acceptable.

On a sidenote I can tell that postbirth depression is something that means a lot to you - maybe you had one or you know someone who had one and I think it is SO great that you stand up for that course! Thank you!
I too think it is SO important that we learn to talk about our feelings, not only when we are pregnant and sick, but always

I'm not sure I follow you. I said that he could act however he wants (i.e. his relationship with Katie Holmes), but doesn't have the right to criticize other people. I'm not judging him for his relationship, I'm judging him because he thinks he's better or smarter than another person and feels that he can publicly judge this person.

However, IMO, the person who loves the girl is the same person who criticizes a woman for treating a disease with medication. We can only hope that Katie Holmes, for her own sake, is as perfect as can be. I haven't had PPD, nor has anyone I know, but I find it disgraceful that a man could act like this- he is the furthest person from being an expert on this subject.