Thank you for your responses
Our puppy has gotten a little more on the chewing and we had been told by our trainer that this stuff called bitter apple was the best stuff to use. So tonight we tried it...he kept grabbing the corner of his puppy pad and pulling it up to play with it so we sprayed it and he HATED it...LOL...he shook his head as if to say YUCK! He hasn't done it again...it is the best stuff since sliced bread!