Oooh controversal topic
Ok - My turn... I think it is a real cute thing and had thought about doing Trixies when I first got her. No, her tail nor her dew claws are done... but I DO think it would be a great addition/tool to use if she needs to be located or verified that she belongs to you. I mean how many other dogs are pierced?? I would not do the tip just because they do play and scratched and they might get caught. Yes I have a baby girl (non Furbaby) and I AM thinking of getting hers done too. I had to wait until I was 16 and I hated it.
But hay - do what YOU want. Everyone has their own opinions but only you have to live with your decition - not them.
If you do get it done, I hope you'll post picts