LOL Funny you should ask, All of our dogs lay on the floor in the dining area until we have finished eating without begging. Then I clear the table and they all gather around me because they know they are next to be fed- dog food-not table scraps- But after dinner my husband always has a snack and here are some pics of how he has to eat his snack because he has shared with them at times. I just tell them no and then they go ask Dad. I guess they got this from my oldest son

Who knows. But Dad is getting better at telling them no and then they will just go lay down. Dad is still in training too.