Ok I think now all Chicken Soups get a 5 star because after further reading the editor of that rating site thought that ethoxyquin was in the meats but Chicken Soup says that it is indeed ethoxyquin free.......anyhoo I think my TWO choices are Chicken Soup for the Puppy Lovers Soul and Fromm's Four Star........my poodle went to Fromm's Four Star after having bad allegic reations and come to thinkn of it he was on SCIENCE DIET

Well I am glad I caught this while my pup is young and can do the change......I'll still be checking into it and reading other brands........I'll let you know what me and Bailey deceided on!