So I was in a similar situation as you except the tooth was NOT wiggly AT ALL. Tough as nails, I thought I would have to get it pulled. THen my friend suggested I get one of her rope toys (the ones with the knots on the ends) and play tug of war with her. I started playing tug of war, giving her hard treats and within two days it was wiggly and by the third it fell into my hand. I was so excited I kept it