Max and Abbie have had all of the pip squeaks and they LOVE them. My mom bought the donkey for Max for christmas one year and he was afraid of it at first. After about a week he realized that it just made noise--it wasn't going to hurt him and he loves playing with them now. Unfortunately, Max and Abbie are both hard chewers so they destroy the poor animals if they are not supervised. The duck is my favorite. The quacking sound is just so cute
dog.com is the cheapest that I've ever seen and if you're on their emailing list, they offer 10% discounts every so often