I get Tatum's from here....
http://www.bullysticks.com/Merchant2...egory_Code=SBS
They still run about $1.70 each but the shipping for me was only $3.50. I get the 6" smoked ones. I recently had to go to Petsmart to get a small package because I waited too long to reorder from the other place and I ended up paying about 6 bucks for 6 sticks that were WAY smaller than what I get at bullysticks.com. The ones BS.com carries are really thick and last Tatum quite a while. The Petsmart one, she had completely GONE in less than 30 minutes.