Shylah still has her's and I think her tail is longer than a docked tail, but not as long as it would be if it wasn't docked. I am not sure what the breeder was thinking. I just make sure when I get her nails clipped that they know to do those too. I can't imagine getting them removed now. That would be like removing your thumb. As far as her tail, I think it looks like a little propeller when she gets excited!! I love it!!