I say Chicken Soup!!! I tried the Innova, but none of them liked it. I have them on Chicken Soup which they all love PLUS it has fatty acids and other natural ingredients in it that help the skin and coat. Since I have put mine on it, their skin is no longer dry, they have beautiful healthy and shiny hair!! I have seen such a HUGE difference since I have put them on Chicken Soup!!!! So, I highly recommend it!!! I get mine at Pet Supplies Plus and I love this brand and am very happy with it and will always feed them this. I have tried some many different brands, this is the one brand that they love and is highly quality food and really helps improve their skin and coat. I give it