I know I already posted on this, but I'm compelled to post again.... IMO (and I'm sure I'm going to be crucified for this) it's an option for those that
really need it.... There are some dogs that are just neurotic and bark and bark for no reason what-so-ever and will continue to do so no matter the amount of discipline or training it receives. It should, however, be used as a
last resort once you've tried all other methods and failed (and NOT just tried each method for a day two, give it a good couple of months to see if it will work).
Some people would just move and that may work for some, but that isn't a viable option for everyone. Lord knows if my landlord was threatening to evict me I'd try to stop that barking quick (but again, I would exhaust every other method first). I can't afford to buy my own house in the middle of nowhere where barking won't bother anyone. I think a lot of people in my situation may feel if they can't stop the barking, their only option is to rehome the dog (and pray that they receive even half the love and attention it did in your home) or give it up to a shelter where it could possibly be euthanized.
Debarking does not completely remove a dogs bark. The dog is still able to bark, it's just more hoarse sounding and doesn't carry as far (in some cases, the dog can actually bark LOUDER than before due to the formation of excessive scar tissue). Some dogs don't even realize that it isn't as loud and isn't psychologically effected at all! Yes it's surgery, yes it has its risks, but it's less invasive than your traditional spay/neuter and when performed by a skilled vet complications should be minimal.... I don't think debarking (it's also referred to as "bark softening") is different from cropping ears, docking tails, removing dew claws and neutering your pet. They ALL are altering your dog in some fashion (it's just more accepted).
I'm not condoning or condemning the procedure. I just don't like when people are being labeled as being "cruel" or "inhumane" for doing something that in the end, could be keeping their beloved pet out of a shelter (and possibly euthanized!) If anyone is considering it as a LAST RESORT, they should discuss it thoroughly with their vet and carefully weigh the pros and cons before going through with it.
An Overview of the Debarking Debate Association of Pet Dog Trainer's Position on Debarking Debarking from Jo Anne Mather
Declawing and Debarking. What are the Alternatives? IACP on Debarking NAIA - Debarking Myths and Facts