As a breeder my contract states the samething.. a replacement pup will be given of the same quality.. Now as a breeder I also know in situations such as yours needs to be looked at on a individual basis.. Now if you didn't want a new pup I think the right thing in this situation would to pay for up to the purchase price on the surgery need to get Sophie taken care of and try to give her a quality life. This is what is the most important over all and should come first. As the owner of this pup this is what I see you wanting for her as well.
Now, if you wanted a replacement pup and keep Sophie as well so she continues to be cared for properly I think this should be honored if you take on the surgery costs.. Because Sophie deserves your love especially going through all of this in the first place...
This is JMO... |