[Jaspermom]

Cesar Select Dinners for Small Dogs with Beef in Meaty Juices
3.5 oz.
Sufficient water for processing, beef by-products, meat by-products, liver, poultry by-products, beef, calcium carbonate, sodium tripolyphosphate, caramel coloring, carrageenan, dried yam, xanthan gum, natural flavors, salt, erythorbic acid, guar gum, potassium chloride, zinc sulfate, sodium nitrite (for color retention), vitamin A, D3, and E supplements, d-calcium pantothenate, thiamine mononitrate (vitamin B1).
*********************************
The popular guideline is to avoid by-products. In the first 4 ingredients, 3 are indeed by-products.

My girls get a teaspoon of Innova Evo twice per day mixed in their dry food.

This is the list of Evo ingredients. They are all human grade.

Turkey
Chicken
Turkey Broth
Chicken Broth
Chicken Meal
Herring
Carrots
Whole Eggs
Salmon Meal
Natural Flavors
Guar Gum
Seaweed Extract
Apples
Tomato Flakes
Cottage Cheese
Herring Oil
Potassium Chloride
Apple Fiber
Inulin
Vitamin C
Sea Salt
Choline Chloride
Sunflower Oil
Beta Carotene
Vitamins/Minerals