Yes, I think Fromm's is nutrionaly very good. Brady is also on a home cooked diet, but she also eats kibble. Fromm's wasn't working out after about a week, she just didn't like it anymore...she's now on Go Natural's Chicken, Fruit and Vegetable formula, I'm very happy with the ingredients and she loves it...AND it's Canadian!
www.petcurean.com if you are curious. Brady has kibble in the morning and homecooked for dinner...
I'm wondering what ingredients do you use for punkin's home cooked food? Did you decide to do a home cooked diet at the recommendation of your vet?