Yes my doggies were removed,but my aunt tells me that some breeders do keep them on and yes ur right about it being inhumane if they were to get them caught on something and ripped off. Honestly I have only seen 2 dogs in my life time with the dew claws still attached. I remember an old woman whos dogs still had them attached and I remember saying y don't u have them removed lol and she hollered at me "Oh no are you crazy" lol thats when I asked about them and a couple of neighbors have told me that there are people who prefer to not have their doggies spayed or neutered or dew clawed or dock tails or ears.
I really am glad to see another side of the story though thank you for your insight.