I am for docking a yorkie tail and a cocker tail and a schnauzer tail oh....I guess any breed that has a docked tail I am for. I don't see the harm in it. Oh, by the way all of my boys were circemcized too. (human) Any way I agree with the post that said don't buy one with a docked tail if you don't want a docked tail. I don't do the docking personally I leave that to my vet. Any way I am for docking. If it were ever outlawed I guess I just wouldn't own a dog that was suppose to have a docked tail.