Thanks for all the suggestions I do have a bark gene but as you would expect it works on Bella but not the problem child

LOL
Sometimes I don't think they know what we want from them and we have to find something to get there attention at the moment they do it so they go Oh you mean you don't want me to bark so much. I wonder if I got one of the spray ones I would only have to use it once or twice and message received .
Lily is a 8 plus lb girl she is full of life and over coming a bone defect called IHOC it is quite rare. While having her nails trimmed at the Vets it was fractured and now seems to be remolding its self. She is a fighter and we love her so much. Bella doesn't alway share our feeling for Lily.
Thanks again for listing