So this is what I came up with. The dark color is supposed to simulate deep ocean water. The paint covered up the gap nicely but you can still see where the paper edges are. I am never going to use Modpodge for glue again. As far as sealer, I have far superior products that I will use up before I use MP.
Still have to cut the wood off, but I've cropped it so the wood won't distract. Also thinking about putting a trim around it for a frame.
P1080871.JPG