Quote:
Originally Posted by Nancy1999  First of all, I’m not the one who thinks I know everything and you all are stupid, I think this type of remark is below the belt. I’m trying to get people to do independent research; I was hesitant to link “The Dog Food Advisor”, because many of you feel that since he’s a dentist, he’s not able to comment on nutrition. I use to think the site wasn’t very good, even the ingredient lists weren’t accurate, but I’ve changed my mind a long time ago way before RC changed it's ingredients, it didn't matter to me RC wasn't a 5 star food, it was considered a good food, and that's was good enough. I do think he’s doing a better job keeping the ingredient list accurate, and he gives the pros and cons to certain ingredients, not just one side, for example, the beet pulp debate. I know you hate the site, you’re an avid Hill’s fan and Hills diets are low rated so you are going to think this guy is an idiot. I wonder if he rated Hills foods as five stars you’d feel the same way? Anyway, I think he has good information to share, and there is even a page that explains the limitations of his site and the problem with all dog food review sites. If nothing else, everyone should read that page. The Problem with Dog Food Reviews. You can get a lot of information from his site, without purchasing anything. My point is to do some research before you automatically believe everything a dog food company says about the food. |
I do think that is what you think, Nancy. I don't know if you really have thought long and hard about the things you have said. The one reference to the food as being crap was pretty low in my honest opinion. And, to suggest that we would be happy feeding sawdust and vitamins? Really?? Not going to go on about this...simply stated how I feel about your posting lately. I have never seen you carry on this much..not sure exactly what it is really about. But, hey we all have things we feel strongly about.
I did not say "the guy is an idiot". The guy just won't be advising me on what to feed my pups. I didn't say there is no good information on his website either. I said he is making money from all of this.
My point in all of this is that I let the companies do the "research" . My reading the websites of the people you quoted is not what I call research.
Not going to argue with you. ALL I did was post the credentials of someone who I trust when it comes to dog food knowledge....AND make a point that the person you advised us to use for such knowledge does indeed make money off of all of this.