Congratulations!! Finley is adorable. He and Huxley make a perfect pair.
Apart from the crying all night, sounds like you are off to a great start. Everything sounds very normal. Maybe Finley didn't want to sleep and wanted to keep playing with his brother.
I hope you have a more peaceful night tonight. No matter what, it's worth it! Look at those sweet little faces. I think they are going to be best buddies. Enjoy!