[Lovetodream88]

Originally Posted by Britster

Jax had really soft poo on RC and 'fattened' up LOL - at least, for him anyway, but he also did on Fromm regular grain inclusives. Oddball.

Fromm Lamb and Beef Grain-Free he LOVES though and seems to do pretty well on, as well as Farmina Cod. Acana Duck is what he always did best on, and he ate Acana in general for over 2yrs, but I haven't tried the 'newer' formulas with him. I was a bit disappointed with the addition of a bunch of lentils, peas, beans etc. But honestly he for sure did best on Acana, always looked the best, muscle tone, stool was the best, no eye boogers, energy, etc.

In general, he SEEMS to do better on either grain-free or minimal grain or limited ingredient. Like, he did fabulous on Purina Beyond lamb - but that's only got like 9 main ingredients. And then he also does/did great on a food like Acana. lol. So I can't exactly pinpoint why he does better IMO on certain foods or not.

For Cody... I don't know, maybe the Acana Duck LID has a shot? They have a new pork food as well, and lamb. All limited ingredient.

Soft poo was one of Callie's issues. Every one of the Fromm Callie tried they all made her break out even the grain free so she can join the odd ball group. I really wish Acana had smaller pieces because Callie loves it but almost acts like it hurts her to chew it yet she chews chews with no problems. I think even if you gave two company's the same recipe the same dog could do good on one but not the other.