Quote:
Originally Posted by yorkietalkjilly  To me, time outs don't train dogs not to do the bad thing it just stops the behavior for the present and they usually re-offended unless retrained in how to properly behave. Most don't have memories long enough to recall the association of why they were removed for long though some might. Those I would put in time out, because they were often troubled dogs, would bark, scratch/dig/destroy, pace in OCD circles or howl during the time-out. It didn't work that well for me. |
I don't know how many times you have tried it, but I have with numerous dogs and it worked out just fine. And, trust me, I have taken in many troubled dogs and they never exhibited such behaviors in a 10 - 15 minute time out. If they did, I probably would be discussing medications with a vet. Now, leave them for long periods and yes, they will do whatever they can to get out of jail. So would I!!! What I am suggesting *IS* retraining in how to properly behave. They quickly learn (usually) that the unacceptable behavior will put them in another place, not the desired place with their people. It just needs to be consistent and constant until they understand.
This is not about memories....this is about taking advantage of associated memory.
Understanding Dog Memory