Thank you for responses.
I will stick with Hill's ID and Freshpet puppy. Just continuing to research since my previous Yorkie (Shelby) died at 8 1/2. She had cancer, a mass in her abdomen, so obviously I question food for a reason.
BTW Acana and Orijen do not make a wet food plus it was too rich for my pup. It's great food, just not for her.