Quote:
Originally Posted by Maximo  I do not believe science has ever been discussed dispassionately at any time in history. Part of the human condition. There is always an agenda.
I also do not believe information is for the few. This is why I said this subject challenges my core beliefs. I advocate spaying/neutering pets, but I do not believe in telling anyone to do anything without thinking. I dumped our first vet for treating me that way.
At the same, I do not like the title of this thread, the "if ever." It suggests a position on the issue that Gail says she does not support for most pets. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wylie's Mom This ^, the bolded parts.
For any owner, I think it's quintessentially important to make INFORMED decisions - no matter what the mainstream is doing. We absolutely *should* understand what we're taking away from our pets when removing their organs, for petes sake!
That's one reason this thread is informative and important and educational. It doesn't have to be a pro-spay-neuter/anti-spay-neuter thread unless people choose to make it that way and read into it that way. |
I don't believe this is about informing/educating yorkie owners. I believe it is anti spay/neuter. I agree that the "if ever" wording speaks volumes.
I also believe that one must consider the audience before attempting to educate. That is not being done....and this breed is already damaged by oopsies as I noted before. Until it is proven that spaying/neutering dogs at a certain age is more damaging that the benefits, I would certainly hope and pray that people would speak with their veterinarians. Some of the things posted online are merely scare tactics. I have been aware of this "movement" for some time and it bothers me greatly that it was begun by the breeding community that seeks to blame everyone but themselves for what has been done to certain breeds...that includes Golden Retrievers...cancers are not from spay/neuter I am so sure. I believe it is due to breeding. Proof? I don't have that...it is simply what I have derived from my vet and a few people who I know who have owned and/or rescued them.
As for yorkies....to suggest that torn CCL's are due to anything but breeding is crazy imo. It is well known that most of those injuries are due to luxating patellas .. and those are considered genetic. Breeders know that, but they are not willing to take the blame for their messes. Instead they are going out of their way to suggest it is early spay/neuter.
