Last Update: So Petey slept thru the night again. He's doing great on the ID food so looks like that's the winner!! Ding, ding, ding! LOL! We'll slowly mix in the dry to the canned and I think we are good to go! He did poop a little this morning, which was harder and back to dark brown so we are good there too. Thanks again for everyone's advice, sharing and support! I love this forum!!