I found a pretty good one at Petsmart last week. I'm not at home so I can't look at the name of it but I think the brand is supposed to be more sturdy toys. They had green and I think orange and it's just basically shaped like a person, kind of like gumby, and the stitching is all around the outer part. There is material that folds over all around the outer edge and that is stitched. Kinda hard to explain. To me the ones that have stitching down the middle right where the squeaker is are really easy for them to destroy. This one also makes noise but it's not really a squeak more like a honk. So far Samson has not destroyed it and it's been almost a week so I think it's a winner. I tried looking on Petsmart.com for the exact name but I didn't see it on there. You could always just stop buying toys and give him empty plastic bottles. It would sure save a lot of money.
Samson has moved on to 2-liters and gallon milk jugs!!