Hmmm anything consumable that's Made in China, I would skip. Have you looked into Beams from the honest kitchen? They're dehydrated catfish skins, my guys LOVE them! Since it's kinda fishy (not that bad tho, compared to another fish treat called Wishes), I only give it to them once a week b4 bath time. Surprisingly, it doesn't give them fishy breath. It's a great source of omega 3's, their hair is so shiny.
Beams - Natural Dehydrated Fish Dog Treats | The Honest Kitchen