Quote:
Originally Posted by Dixies Mom  To be quite honest, I do not know how you are expecting me to answer your question. I have my own procedures for my breeding program. |
I don't think the questions would be that hard to answer. "If the pup was your pup and it was bought from you, how would you handle it and/or what would your contract say for you to do?"
A lot of people have chimed in on how they would have handed it...breeders and non-breeders alike.
It may be difficult for someone to answer at this point when they don't have all of the date, facts or medical records and results in front of them though. But if, it turns out that the pup is indeed sick and was sick when it was initially sold to Sheila, and there are facts that back that up...then IMO, it's a pretty straightforward question.
Since you aren't the breeder though...it's not going to make much of a difference in how or if you answer it, so please don't think I am in way asking or trying to pressure you into answering...
I think a lot of people believe what Sheila is saying, simply because they have no reason to doubt her. I am not sure what motives she would have to come on here and lie and cause herself a bunch of stress over a puppy. However, I do understand, since she has the puppy and is the only one who can take it to the vet, burden of proof is on her...and luckily, she's said she will provide proof.
If Sheila is just this bad person...who is lying and is out to defame Judy, why on earth would Judy want to do a replacement and give her another puppy to care for?? If she was that bad, it seems like Judy would just want to give her the money back, get her puppy back and cut tie
I started to think about what others would say if one of the well known and well liked breeders was going through this, instead of Judy...and I am sure there would be lots of people defending them. On the other hand, I'd like to believe that most wouldn't have let it escalate to the point that it has gotten in this case.
s.