I give this to all three of the pups, but not the human supplement.  Piccolo's vet dermatologist recommended glucosamine and chondroitin and she said it didn't really matter what form in which it is received (not sure she was talking about human supplement though), so I give all three Jake's Hip Treats.  They love it. 
 
For me, I tried taking glucosamine and chondroitin... Not sure how to say this delicately, so will just say it.  It was causing huge problems with gas.  
