Your story sounds just like mine
I started out with Natural Balance and Jada thrived on it. Then comes the recall so I switch to California Natural and now two recalls back to back, so I went searching again. Right now I am trying out a small bag of Earthborn Holistic and still in the transition period.
Good luck in your search, I know how hard it is. I'm praying that Jada does well on the Earthborn as it has 5 star rating and no recalls and an added bonus I can buy it locally( I have to order kibble online normally).