Science Diet is one of the most reputable companies for dog food. I would NOT remove it from the list.
Here is a great food that I feed my pups and they are doing fantastic.
Grain Free Natural Chicken & Potato Recipe Adult - Dry
Or they have salmon:
Grain Free Natural Salmon & Potato Recipe Adult - Dry
As for Dog Food Advisor, to each his own. My understanding is that he is a human dentist. I prefer consulting with veterinary nutritionists as I believe they have the education and first hand experience regarding my pups' nutritional needs.