[sganow]

I think you'll find some bad reviews of any food out there. Having said that, I would still try to find one that has the least amount of negative reviews. The store I buy from recommends Horizon foods (Horizon Legacy, Amicus, Pulsar) and also Fromm foods. My dogs have done well on Legacy and Amicus and they also like Fromm. I rotate so they get variety. By the way, Horizon is a small Canadian company that makes their foods in their own facility using locally sourced ingredients.