Honest Kitchen is an excellent brand (especially the Love and Zeal formulas...those are definitely the 2 that I would feed if I were going to use it as the main food source) and I've used many of the sample and small packs as toppers...THK looks kinda unappealing when rehydrated but Toki really loved it! I would make it the night before and add extra warm water in the morning with breakfast to make it soupy and mix it in with her kibbles. I hope those foods work out for your pups and kitties! Keep us posted