Ok I will add my two cents. Levi had done well on the Wellness simple solutions duck...but I wanted to get away from wellness. Tried From game bird he itched until he was almost bleeding. I felt horrible. So we are back on wellness...which he does well on but company makes me nervous. Canine Caviar has a duck formula? You have tried it with success? thanks. Lily my little peanut can eat anything, go figure