Haha!!! I'm really too good at all of this! I hope it didn't upset you when I said I figured the clue out, Courtney. I had to keep it to myself...well, I talked my bf's ear off for ages about how all the clues fit Luma except the Elmo clue. I looked up Elmos wiki page and was looking at his birthday and trying ti see any similarities...then it dawned on me