[MY OSCAR]

Originally Posted by lovespandp

I am trying this food because DH picked it and wants to try it on Peanut- I don't think Peanut is some allergic dog and needs to be on some crazy RX diet. He was on Acana for ever and did great, the last bag of Acana started making him itch like crazy- I had to find a new food for him, Brothers is what DH found hence that is why we are trying it-

I don't know why he was itching, all I know is he has never itched on Acana before, then we bought a new bag with the "new formula" and he started itching like crazy!

I just want to find a dog food that works- If this food doesn't work I will find another one, it is just food.

Some people have strong opinions, and that is fine. However you have to look at the big picture- Acana is this marvelous company, many people love them and many dogs loved their food and did well on their food- All of a sudden they changed the formula and now I hear of a lot of itchy dogs- Just like Science Diet issue- Not too many people like them, but I have heard of a lot of dogs doing well on that food- Who is to say what is right for a dog- We can all have our opinions, but what is going to matter is how well your dog does on the food you pick!