[MY OSCAR]

Originally Posted by lindseyeliza

I'm looking to switch my lil pupper Maddie to a grain-free food (and distilled water) in hopes to clear up her eye gunk and I've kind of narrowed the choices down to these two, but they seem almost the same to me.

Both have not-too-high protein and fat contents for her little body, and good wholesome first ingredients. I like that these two foods have 1/2 cup feeding recommendation for her 6 pound frame. Some other foods have the same calories spread over more than a whole cup, which I think is a waste. Neither has beet pulp which I think I read the beet pulp can make the stains worse... could be wrong, not sure. Wellness is more turkey while Blue is more chicken, but I'm not sure that matters. Prices are similar...

Not sure if there's any glaring reason to choose one over the other. Any thoughts?

i just started my oscar on buffalo blue wilderness duck recipe.(grain free)
i am very pleased with it.
he is doing great on it.
i was feeding Acana but they changed the formula and it did not agree with him
i personally prefer BB over Wellness
maybe you could request some samples.
also if you go to the BB website and do a short survey they will send you a $5 coupon

i think either one would be a good choice but it mostly depends on your dog and which food suits him/her best...
good luck