I don't pay attention to those lists anymore. Notice a lot of those foods were just part of the big recall.
Don't get caught up on stars, etc. I like that review site for the purpose of looking up ingredients, etc... but I pay more attention to consumer reviews, and quality control, where the food is produced.
I wish Royal Canin would get their own plant (currently they're owned by Mars - Pedigree, the candies Twix, Wrigley gum, Skittles, etc, etc, are made) and change up a few ingredients personally, but I still think they're a decent food from a good company. I'm actually not exactly sure where their food is specifically made, in what state, etc. Haven't looked into it.