I got him the small size Deere antler and he has loved it. He has chewed on it last night and got it the first thing this morning and he has carried it all around the house. I have bought alot of thing for him to chew on and this by far has been the best. I think when I go back I am going to get him another one that is a different shape. I thought about the bully stick but I didn't won't it to get all over my rugs. He is on the couch with me chewing on his antler right now. Lol he has it in his mouth and he has fell asleep.