I highly recommend Neutrogena Skin ID
skiniD Personalized Acne Treatment - Neutrogena skiniD - Neutrogena skiniD
My younger daughter used it and got back her beautiful skin in no time. It's much more specific than Proactive and has many different formulas. I remember when I went on their site to answer all the questions for her, it gave me one formula but then after talking to a representative she actually changed one of the numbers (I believe it was the cleanser) because she thought the one it told me was a little too harsh for her age. What she ended up with was 14,32,72. That will make more sense when you look at the site. She's been using it over two years and we've only had to buy the entire set maybe 3 times. Mostly we just have to get a cream cleanser in between buying all 3 items. It will set you up for automatic renewals but you can ask them to extend it quite a ways out. I just make a note on the calendar as to when it will automatic ship and will call them a few weeks before to extend it out another 6 months if I don't think we'll need the whole set. And she does not use the Skin ID moisturizer. She uses Purpose moisturizer (recommended by our dermatologist and much cheaper!).
You should google search for a coupon because there's usually a $10 one out there.
Oh, and this was suggested to me by another YT user who's daughter had great results. Now I can't remember who it was but we are very grateful!