It is SO hard to decide!! I am going through this right now as well. Lexie has been on Merricks since she was a baby. Recently with some of her health issues (seizures) I am re-thinking her food (she wasn't crazy about it anyways
There is so much information and so many choices. I don't mind paying for a GREAT quality food. I just want one that is free from recalls (becoming more and more of an issue) that she will actually eat and like, and that I am able to get somewhat easily. We are currently trialing Blue Buffalo. She does seem to like it. I may try TOTW as well.... hmmm... choices, choices..