Thank you so much all, you put my mind at ease. The only problem I'm having now is that she's never had anything other than her puppy ice cream, kibble and organic (kinda boring) treats. I introduced this to her and now she thinks it's the best thing since peanut butter. Trying to make a puppy understand that it's medicine and not a treat is like trying to make Godzilla understand why he can't walk in the street.
Thank you again for your valued (and valuable) input!