It never came to mind that she was hitting or smacking the dog for any other purpose then trying to get the dog off her daughter. Not to punish or hurt the dog. But as I said above, even in that case it can still cause a negative reaction from the dog that'll only cause them to grip on, or come after her daughter again out of fear and defensiveness...
Another recommendation I could give it geting a personal trianer to work with you and your family one-on-one. |