Good evening!
I
hate when I'm used to something for years, and then it goes away!! It always 'throws' me - and I end up spending a fortune getting something I try to like instead aargh! Also when they say 'new improved' - it rarely is!!!
Have you tried emailing Clinique and explaining your predicament? Ask them what they would suggest is an equivalent alternative within their range?
Personally - Clarins or Estee Lauder or Lancome for me (or the Body Shop if you have them?). I hope you manage to get it sorted, Sally x