Troy is on Blue Buffalo. Troy can be picky and will want a switch in diet after 3 months. Troy has been on Blue since May and he hasn't tired of it yet. I know that his coat is shiny, stools are firm and regular and he likes it. I haven't tried Natural Balance with Troy but have tried it with my other dogs and it was a good food for them also. I tried their lamb formula. They had very stinky gas with it and it didn't subside. Not sure why.
I think both have grain free versions and I don't think you can go wrong either way. They are both readily available at PetsMart so you don' t need to make a special trip to a speciality store and are responsibly priced. Since you have a guarantee I'd just try which ever one you feel would most fit your home.
__________________  Owned by Troy(RIP) & Emma
|