Aww, Jada looks adorable cuddling with her yellow loofah.
I am facing a similar problem with Max, although he likes other toys for playtime. His favorite is his security blanket and friend. It is the Ty Bow Wow Weenie Beanie:
Amazon.com: Ty Bow Wow Beanies Weenie the...
He takes it for "walks" around the house after meals or when he is excited. I bought several of them, but he knows the original one that he has had since he was a tiny pup.
Teddy has been chewing on it the last couple of days and now I need to sew up a couple holes on it.
I hope Jada will take to the new toy.