[alaskayorkie]

My wife and I are split on the bottom. She says Haley. I say Lauren.

Haley's inconsistent, but I think her best songs, House of the Rising Sun and her second song tonight, are among the best of the season.

I think Lauren is solid, but doesn't have "it'" as Simon would say.

Scottie is goofy and I didn't like his second song, but he's got a golden voice and deserves to stay in there on that alone.

James is the whole package and still my favorite. My wife's too.