[Lou]

Originally Posted by T-Rox

I'm happy with these results. I agree that Thia can only get stronger, she was kind of getting lost among the contestants almost like she was trying to not be seen. But can we talk about those guest performances??! Awful awful awful. I mean come on now. Fantasia's collard greens and corn bread = worst song ever. I had to change it. I don't mean to be so harsh but I can't believe she was a winner on AI. That must have been the tone deaf season.

She was FABULOUS the year she won. I had her picked as the winner from her first audition! Her last song she did sitting on the stage. It was that old song "Summertime." And she was like I said - fabulous.
She really hasn't progress since then and in fact has digressed.

I beg to differ with you on the worst song ever. Right after she won AI she released a song title "Baby Daddy" and IT was the worst song ever. She might have written in herself. I remember hearing it on the radio and going home telling dh about it. I was laughing my butt off because it was so stupid. Sigh. What a waste of talent.